Saying goodbye to an old friend


Screenshot of the Better web site, showing the Better badge in front of clouds. Reads: Better 1996-2021

How enact you adore them apples? We didn’t and wretched Better paid the price.

Trillion-dollar companies are not your friend.

This isn’t a revelation to me. I’ve been announcing it for a while now. And but, over time, I’ve taken my fragment of flack for seeing Apple as a viable mainstream stopgap fixed with its enterprise model.

Well, that space has become untenable ever since Apple announced, got slammed for, doubled-down on, delayed, and at remaining, with iOS 15.2, began drip feeding us the adjustments in an try and slowly boil frogs because it continues with its plans to put into effect client-side scanning on iPhones, iPads, and Macs.

Apple didn’t near up with the client-side scanning concept, by the potential, William Barr and Trump’s justice department did (moreover read the follow-up):

The suddenness of this unusual push is alarming. Furthermore grand is that every one of sudden the fundamental reason to demonize encryption is CSAM, with terrorism and reasonably about a ills taking half in second fiddle. Whilst currently as tiring July 2019, when Barr revived his predecessors’ habit of castigating encrypted carrier suppliers, it used to be drug cartels he invoked. But CSAM is the dominant level of curiosity now, all without delay and thoroughly.

It is beyond demand that CSAM is a staunch and severe pronounce of affairs … It is radioactive, it’s a ways illegal in all locations, and no legitimate firm desires it on their servers. Nonetheless, this unusual single-minded level of curiosity on CSAM within the revived anti-encryption push appears as if an exceedingly cynical transfer on the section of the U.S. authorities. Out of the Four Horsemen of the Infocalypse (terrorism, drug trafficking, CSAM, and organized crime), terrorism didn’t work to shriek public understanding in opposition to encryption, so the authorities has switched horse(men) midstream.

One proposal for enabling legislation enforcement catch entry to is to originate a system where the provider … would take a look at shriek material, such as a characterize linked to a message, before it’s encrypted and transmitted to another user – i.e. while the shriek material is on the sender’s diagram, not traveling thru the provider’s server – to examine out to resolve out whether that shriek material is or would be abusive shriek material such as CSAM.

A truly lengthy time coming

My disenchantment with Apple has been a lengthy time coming.

It hasn’t helped that since we moved to Eire and situation up Puny Expertise Basis, we haven’t been ready to catch Apple to transfer our developer myth over from our used organisation based within the UK to the unusual one here in Eire.

In fact, we were going to cease Better then as we couldn’t afford to withhold two organisations going however we obtained a proposal from Apple to form things out. I naïvely took them at their be aware and announced it as “a overjoyed ending.”

Appropriate afterwards, Apple went totally silent on us.

We haven’t heard a single be aware from them over the remaining two years even after we closed down the used organisation (that our Apple developer myth is nonetheless technically linked to) and even supposing we contacted their workplaces in Eire to follow up.

So there’s that.

(Realize that here’s something they happily enact for colossal companies. It’s just that a two-particular person not-for-profit is subsequent to nugatory in their eyes.)

As I wrote on the time:

[T]his is just how lifestyles is while you happen to’re going thru trillion-dollar faceless companies. It’s totally one causes why it’s so vital that we fund and fetch human-scale minute tech as an replacement to the strangehold of enormous tech on our lives.

Then, they went and killed offline net apps.

After which they began using your data to enable third occasions to accommodate you (however acknowledged it used to be OK since the general data used to be to your possess diagram1).

After which they continued collecting an increasing number of knowledge about us that we were assured would care for on our possess gadgets except we desired to fragment it.

After which they reneged on the remaining bit with their plans to put into effect client-side scanning.

After which I currently had a chilling chat with an ex-Apple worker and realised that the stuff we hear is just the tip of the iceberg. (Howdy, Tim Cook, while you happen to dispute “privateness is a human just” however withhold it from your possess workers, does that mean you undoubtedly don’t think that it’s a human just or that you don’t think your workers are human beings?)

Anyway, none of this makes me are searching out for to write down another line of code for or spend another cent on the gadgets of this kind of firm.

This apple is depraved to its core and I’m completed with it.

So, what subsequent?

We originate the Puny Web.

We toughen replacement working systems.

We support and toughen folks like Pine64, Starlabs, Purism, and Machine76 who are constructing possible decisions.

We envision and fetch a world where your supreme replacement is to not be shackled to the whims of fucking trillion-dollar companies.

Who’s with me?

Be a half of the pack! Be a half of 8000+ others registered users, and catch chat, put teams, put up updates and put chums world broad!



Hey! look, i give tutorials to all my users and i help them!