CSIS Briefs

January 13, 2022

The Jabber

If peace talks fail, the Russian navy has loads of alternatives to approach into Ukraine through northern, central, and southern invasion routes. But a Russian attempt to employ and retain territory will no longer primarily be easy and may maybe well maybe also possible be impacted by challenges from weather, urban combat, expose and alter, logistics, and the morale of Russian troops and the Ukrainian population. America and its European allies and partners wishes to be willing for an invasion by taking instantaneous financial, diplomatic, navy, intelligence, and humanitarian steps to attend Ukraine and its population and shore up defenses alongside the North Atlantic Treaty Group’s (NATO) eastern flank.

Introduction

Russian president Vladimir Putin continues to threaten an invasion of Ukraine with a indispensable navy buildup terminate to the Russian-Ukrainian border and aggressive language. Russia has deployed offensive weapons and systems inner inserting distance of Ukraine, including main fight tanks, self-propelled howitzers, infantry combating autos, loads of originate rocket systems, Iskander immediate-vary ballistic missile systems, and towed artillery, as highlighted in Figures 1a and 1b. Putin has complemented this buildup with blunt language that Ukraine is historically segment of Russia and that Kiev wishes to approach to the Russian fold.¹ Russia’s threat is namely alarming for at the least two causes. First, Russia may maybe well maybe switch its pre-positioned forces into Ukraine immediate. If fully committed, the Russian navy is tremendously stronger and further high quality than Ukraine’s navy, and the USA and other NATO international locations beget made it sure they received’t deploy their forces to Ukraine to repel a Russian invasion. Even supposing diplomats reach an settlement, Putin has shown a willingness to dial up—and down—the war in Ukraine and threaten to develop the war, making the Russian threat chronic. Second, an invasion would impress a indispensable switch in world politics, constructing a fresh “Iron Curtain” that begins alongside Russia’s borders with Finland and the Baltic states and strikes south through Jap Europe, the Middle East, Central and South Asia, and now not at the moment to East Asia alongside China’s southern flank.

In consequence, it is serious to include how Russia may maybe well maybe invade Ukraine, how train political wishes may maybe well maybe also influence an invasion idea, the challenges an invasion may maybe well maybe also face, and what alternatives the USA and its European partners beget to acknowledge. To abet realize these dynamics, this immediate asks loads of questions. What are Russian president Vladimir Putin’s wishes? What navy alternatives does Russia beget, and what may maybe well maybe an invasion behold like? How must the USA and its allies and partners acknowledge?

The immediate makes two main arguments. First, if Russia decides to invade Ukraine to reassert Russian alter and influence, there are at the least three that you just will be ready to factor in axes of approach to employ Ukrainian territory: a northern thrust, perhaps attempting to outflank Ukrainian defenses spherical Kiev by drawing advance through Belarus; a central thrust advancing due west into Ukraine; and a southern thrust advancing across the Perekop isthmus. Second, if the USA and its European partners fail to deter a Russian invasion, they must toughen Ukrainian resistance through a mix of diplomatic, navy, intelligence, and other capability. America and its European partners can’t allow Russia to annex Ukraine. The West’s appeasement of Moscow when it annexed Crimea in 2014 after which orchestrated an insurgency in Jap Ukraine simplest emboldened Russian leaders. To boot, Russian annexation of some or all of Ukraine would enlarge Russian manpower, industrial capability, and pure resources to a level that can well maybe assemble it a world threat. America and Europe can’t assemble this mistake all any other time.

The relaxation of this immediate is divided into three main sections. First, it examines Russian political wishes. Second, the immediate analyzes Russian navy alternatives. Third, it explores alternatives readily available to the USA and its allies and partners.

Figure 1a: Russian Military Buildup terminate to Yelnya, Russia

Figure 1b: Shut-Up of Russian Military Buildup terminate to Yelnya, Russia

Russian Political Dreams

The Kremlin wants what it says: an end to NATO expansion, a rollback of previous expansion, a elimination of American nuclear weapons from Europe, and a Russian sphere of influence. Nonetheless, Putin may maybe well maybe also accept much less. The Kremlin’s main just is a guarantee that Belarus, Ukraine, and Georgia received’t ever belong to a navy or financial bloc rather than the ones Moscow controls and that Russia continuously is the final arbitrator of the foreign and safety policy of all three states. In essence, this battle is about whether or no longer 30 years after the death of the Soviet Union, its gentle ethnic republics can reside as self enough, sovereign states or in the occasion that they still must acknowledge Moscow as their de facto sovereign.

Ostensibly, the inquire for an irregular sphere of influence in Jap Europe and the south Caucasus is to fulfill Russian safety pursuits. The Kremlin has portrayed NATO expansion to the east as the distinctive sin of put up-Soviet world family with the West that now wishes to be rectified. Details, alternate interpretations, and the security concerns of equally sovereign countries however, Moscow claims that without such guarantees, this can employ navy power to guard its safety pursuits.

Russian Military Recommendations

In accordance with these political wishes, the Kremlin has at the least six that you just will be ready to factor in navy alternatives:

1. Redeploy a couple of of its ground forces away from the Ukrainian border—at the least immediate—if negotiations are a success nonetheless proceed to attend pro-Russian rebels in Jap Ukraine.

2. Send extinct Russian troops into the breakaway regions of Donetsk and Luhansk as unilateral “peacekeepers” and refuse to withdraw them till peace talks end successfully and Kiev is of the same opinion to place in power the Minsk Accords.

3. Grab Ukrainian territory as a long way west as the Dnepr River to employ as a bargaining chip or incorporate this fresh territory fully into the Russian Federation. This option is represented in Figure 2a.

4. Grab Ukrainian territory up to the Dnepr River and employ an further belt of land (to incorporate Odessa) that connects Russian territory with the breakaway Transdniestria Republic and separates Ukraine from any entry to the Sunless Sea. The Kremlin would incorporate these fresh lands into Russia and assemble sure that that the rump Ukrainian statelet remains economically unviable.

5. Grab simplest a belt of land between Russia and Transdniestria (including Mariupol, Kherson, and Odessa) to stable freshwater presents for Crimea and block Ukraine’s entry to the sea, whereas warding off indispensable combat over Kiev and Kharkiv. This option is represented in Figure 2b.

6. Grab all of Ukraine and, with Belarus, boom the formation of a fresh tripartite Slavic union of Massive, Tiny, and White Russians (Russians, Ukrainians, and Belarusians). This option would own operations represented in Figure 2a as “segment one,” with Figure 2c representing “segment two” of this selection.

Of those six alternatives, the indispensable two are the least possible to incur indispensable world sanctions nonetheless beget puny probability of accomplishing a step forward on both NATO points or the Minsk Accords on account of their coercive nature. All other alternatives bring indispensable world sanctions and financial hardship and would be counterproductive to the just of weakening NATO or decoupling the USA from its commitments to European safety.

Recommendations three through six may maybe well maybe cease one other just—the destruction of an self enough Ukraine—whose evolution against a liberal democratic say has become a indispensable supply of contention among the many Kremlin’s safety elites. Option three would beget Russia alter a appreciable amount of Ukrainian territory nonetheless still leave it as an economically viable say. Option four leaves simplest an agrarian rump Ukraine nonetheless precludes occupying its most nationalistic areas. Option 5 leaves extra of Ukraine free nonetheless still cuts its entry to the sea and incurs fewer occupation costs. Recommendations four and 5—seizing a belt of land from Tiraspol to Mariupol—are sophisticated by the truth that there may maybe be now not such a thing as a east-west working pure characteristic, river, or mountain vary that can well maybe aid as a pure line of demarcation for this occupied land. The fresh border alongside this territory would walk across endless fields and forests and be advanced to shield. Option six capability occupying the general nation and going in the course of the assimilation of a population of 41 million that will resist occupation actively and passively for years. It can well well require an occupation power of appreciable size to control the population and man the fresh borders with NATO international locations. Ukrainians in any occupied territory can quiz compelled Russification that the nation experienced below such rulers as Catherine the Massive, Alexander II, Stalin, and Brezhnev.

That you just will be ready to deem Invasion Routes

Ideological preparation of Russian society for a battle with Ukraine has been ongoing since at the least 2014, with Kremlin propaganda portraying Ukraine as a proto-fascist, neo-Nazi say. In July 2021, a public letter by President Putin asserted that Russians and Ukrainians are the same other folks and castigated Ukraine’s authorities for justifying independence by denying its past.² The Russian navy made President Putin’s article compulsory studying for its squaddies.³ This was once followed in October by a letter in the newspaper Kommersant by Russian Security Council vice-president Dmitry Medvedev, which stale antisemitic tones to delegitimize the fresh Ukrainian management as extremist, imperfect, and foreign managed.⁴

With an ideological foundation for action in situation, the next movement is to fabricate a casus belli—justification for war—per the Kremlin-manufactured image of Ukraine. Pretexts for an assault may maybe well maybe vary from a easy breakdown of safety talks to a stage-managed incident equal to the provocations at Mukden, Gleiwitz, and Mainila that provided justification for Japan’s invasion of Manchuria, Germany’s invasion of Poland, and the Soviet Union’s assault on Finland, respectively. Here’s why the abnormal divulge of Protection Minister Sergey Shoigu posted on the Kremlin’s legitimate web score 22 situation of American mercenaries making ready a “provocation” with chemical weapons in Ukraine is ominous and may maybe well maybe foreshadow staunch the assemble of “incident” the Kremlin would prepare.⁵

Once there may maybe be a casus belli, cyberattacks will possible apply to degrade Ukraine’s navy expose and alter systems and public communications and electrical grids. Subsequent, kinetic operations will possible originate with air and missile strikes against Ukraine’s air power and air defense systems. Once air superiority is established, Russian ground forces would switch forward, a minute preceded by particular operations to degrade further expose and alter capabilities and prolong the mobilization of reserves by conducting bombings, assassinations, and sabotage operations.

The scheme of maneuver of a Russian navy invasion of Ukraine will possible be influenced through which of the above political targets the Kremlin wishes to cease, the geography of the land and cities to be fought over, and the transportation routes to bring up logistics. If the Kremlin wishes to exercise alternatives three, four, or six, and bearing in tips main geography and logistics, there are three possible axes of approach to employ Ukrainian territory east of the Dnepr River, with the river as both a restrict of approach or the indispensable segment line of a elevated invasion.

• Northern Route: Russia may maybe well maybe approach against Kiev alongside two routes. The first would be 150 miles by avenue through Novye Yurkovichi, Russia; Chernihiv, Ukraine; and into Kiev, Ukraine. The 2d would be a 200-mile thrust through Troebortnoe, Russia; Konotop, Ukraine; Nizhyn, Ukraine; and into Kiev.⁶ If Minsk were to acquiesce to the utilization of its avenue and rail networks, the Russian navy may maybe well maybe outflank Ukrainian defenses spherical Kiev and advance them from the rear via a 150-mile axis of approach from Mazur, Belarus, to Korosten, Ukraine, and now not at the moment to Kiev.
• Central Route: Russia may maybe well maybe moreover approach due west alongside three routes. The first may maybe well maybe consist of a 200-mile axis that strikes through Belgorod, Russia; Kharkiv, Ukraine; Poltava, Ukraine; and now not at the moment to Kremenchuk, Ukraine. The 2d may maybe well maybe consist of a 140-mile axis thrust through Donetsk, Ukraine to Zaporizhzhia, Ukraine; and perhaps moreover one other thrust from Donetsk to Dnipro, Ukraine. The third may maybe well maybe own Russian forces advancing alongside the shoreline against Mariupol, Berdyansk, and the Perekop isthmus connecting Crimea to Ukraine.
• Southern Route: Russia may maybe well maybe moreover approach across the Perekop isthmus to beget Kherson and the supply of freshwater for Crimea and concurrently against the vicinity of Melitopol to hyperlink up with Russian forces advancing alongside the fly of the Sea of Azov. If Russia was once to attempt option 5, this continuously is the indispensable assault coupled with the assault alongside the shoreline against Mariupol and Berdyansk. But it completely would be hardest to abet logistically on account of the inability of a railway working alongside the Sea of Azov fly and the indispensable route of approach.

Figure 2 highlights that you just will be ready to factor in invasion routes. All of those routes, except the coastal one, parallel present rail traces. Here’s indispensable since Russian navy logistics forces are no longer designed for effectively-organized-scale ground offensives removed from railroads.⁷ If Russia’s wishes consist of denying Ukraine future entry to the sea, this can beget to employ Odessa. Some predict that this would be finished via amphibious and airborne landings terminate to Odessa, which hyperlink up with mechanized forces drawing advance from the east. If Russia intends to conquer the general nation, its forces would must employ Odessa (whose port facilities would ease Russian logistics) and moreover disagreeable the Dnepr River at loads of aspects to march and fight an further 350 to 700 miles further west to beget all of Ukraine up to its borders with Poland, Slovakia, Hungary, Romania, and Moldova.

Figure 2: That you just will be ready to deem Russian Invasion Routes

Russian Possibilities of Success

Mechanized attacks are no longer repeatedly as posthaste as attackers hope. Two of the quickest actions of armored forces in historic past—German usual Heinz Guderian’s punch in the course of the Ardennes and seizure of Dunkirk in Would possibly perhaps well maybe 1940, and the U.S. and coalition approach from the Kuwait border to Baghdad in 2003—every averaged roughly 20 miles per day. Circulation against a obvious foe in winter stipulations with puny daylight may maybe well maybe decrease that fee of approach tremendously.

With enough troops, firepower, logistics, time, and nationwide will, as effectively as no commence air interference, Russia may maybe well maybe grind forward till its navy achieves the Kremlin’s political wishes. Russia’s navy outnumbers Ukraine’s navy in the air and on the bottom, Russia gained wide ride in conducting blended-hands operations in Syria, and the terrain favors offensive mechanized battle. Nonetheless, the staunch calculation of navy success can simplest be taken after a conflict of hands begins. To boot, there are a variety of intangibles—comparable to weather, urban combat, expose and alter, logistics, and morale—that will play a indispensable just in the preliminary stages of a war.

Weather: An invasion that begins in January or February would beget the wait on of frozen ground to toughen the disagreeable-nation movement of a effectively-organized mechanized power. It can well well moreover indicate working in stipulations of freezing frigid and puny visibility. January is in total the coldest and snowiest month of the 300 and sixty five days in Ukraine, averaging 8.5 hours of daylight right in the course of the month and rising to 10 hours by February.⁸ This would assign apart a top class on night combating capabilities to retain an approach transferring forward. Ought to still combating proceed into March, mechanized forces would beget to kind out the inappropriate Rasputitsa, or thaw. In October, Rasputitsa turns company ground into mud. In March, the frozen steppes thaw, and the land all any other time turns into at simplest a bog, and at worst a sea of mud. Winter weather is moreover no longer up to optimum for adequate terminate air toughen operations.

Metropolis Fight: While powerful of the terrain east of the Dnepr River entails rural fields and forests, there are a variety of indispensable urban areas that a Russian mechanized power would beget to both beget or bypass and besiege. Kiev has nearly 3 million inhabitants, Kharkiv has roughly 1.5 million, Odessa has 1 million, Dnipro has nearly 1 million, Zaporizhia has 750,000, and even Mariupol has nearly 500,000.⁹ If defended, these effectively-organized urban areas may maybe well maybe beget appreciable time and casualties to sure and beget. Within the First Chechen Battle, it took Russian forces from December 31, 1994, to February 9, 1995, to battle alter of Grozny, then a city of no longer up to 400,000, from a couple of thousand Chechen warring parties.¹⁰ Within the Second Chechen Battle, the siege of Grozny moreover took six weeks.

Attributable to this truth, primarily the most efficient route of action for Russian troops would be to avoid urban areas and mop them up later. Nonetheless, Kharkiv is staunch over the border from Russia and is a indispensable avenue and railroad junction. If Russian forces did no longer alter Kharkiv, it may maybe well well maybe severely diminish their logistical capability to toughen a central thrust against the Dnepr River and beyond. Furthermore, Kiev poses a identical direct and, as the nation’s capital, possesses mountainous symbolic fee for whichever aspect holds it. Russia may maybe well maybe be unable to retain away from sustained urban combat in loads of indispensable metropolitan areas (and the resulting excessive casualties) if it makes an attempt bigger than a punitive incursion into Ukraine.

Expose and Preserve watch over: There is a Russian expression: “the indispensable blini is repeatedly a mess.” Within the case of an invasion of Ukraine, Russia will most certainly be conducting its largest blended hands operation for the reason that War of Berlin in 1945. The 2008 Russo-Georgian Battle saw staunch 5 days of combat and engaged 70,000 Russian squaddies.¹¹ In Syria, the indispensable maneuver forces included Syrian ground objects, with abet from Lebanese Hezbollah, militia forces from neighboring international locations comparable to Iraq and Afghanistan, inner most navy corporations comparable to the Wagner Community, and Iran’s Islamic Innovative Guard Corps-Quds Forces. But Russia did no longer deploy indispensable numbers of extinct forces. Roughly 120,000 Russian squaddies are mobilized terminate to Ukraine, with tens of hundreds extra ready to deploy into combat.¹² This is able to well also be a direct for Russian expose and alter to first switch all of those forces into their assault positions with staunch march discipline. This is able to well moreover be advanced for Russia to retain that discipline right in the course of the assault in reveal that the extensive portions of autos and squaddies transferring on a puny replace of slippery and unhappy roads and continuously at night cease no longer become one spacious traffic jam.

The coordination of airborne and amphibious assaults will expose one other direct. While airborne forces would be dropped alongside the Dnepr River to employ indispensable bridges, how lengthy would they be ready to retain out whereas armored forces attempt and reach them over winter roads? The identical applies for amphibious forces attempting to outflank Ukrainian defenses terminate to Mariupol or to employ Odessa. Sunless Sea hydrography and coastal topography provide few factual landing web sites for amphibious forces, and once landed, they would be onerous to abet.¹³ With out staunch coordination and posthaste approach of armored forces, any airborne or amphibious assault as segment of the invasion may maybe well maybe become a “bridge or seashore too a long way” for Russian forces. Figures 3a, 3b, and 3c highlight ships from the Russian navy’s Sunless Sea Immediate, including landing ships and corvettes that would be stale in an amphibious assault into Ukraine.

Figure 3a: Sevastopol Bay, Crimea

Figure 3b: Shut-Up of Russian Landing Ships in Sevastopol

Figure 3c: Shut-Up of Russian Maritime Vessels in Sevastopol

The Russian navy moreover has puny ride in coordinating a effectively-organized replace of plane that will toughen the bottom assault. Russian air operations in Syria and Chechnya cease no longer review with the replace of sorties that would be required in Ukraine across a entrance perhaps loads of hundred miles extensive. This is able to well maybe also be the indispensable time since World Battle II that Russia’s ground forces will face a new mechanized opponent, and its air forces will face an opponent with a new air power and air defense machine. In consequence, Russian forces will possible face necessary challenges in expose, alter, communications, and coordination.

Logistics: The preliminary assault will possible be effectively supported with artillery and air toughen, leading to loads of breakthroughs in Ukrainian defenses. Nonetheless, once combat objects employ their preliminary stores of ammunition, gasoline, and meals, the train test of Russian navy energy will originate—including Russia’s ability to abet the approach of a extensive mechanized power over hundreds of miles of territory. Kiev and the Dnepr River crossings are at the least 150 to 200 avenue miles from the Russian border, and its navy will require at the least loads of days of combating to reach them. Before that, they’ll indubitably beget to resupply, refuel, and change combat losses of males and field cloth at the least once, which is ready to require an operational end.

In his article “Feeding the Undergo,” Alex Vershinin argues that there are extreme logistical challenges to a Russian invasion that is supposed to roll over the Baltic states in 96 hours and expose the West with a fait accompli. Russia has constructed an sharp war machine for combating terminate to its frontier and inserting deep with lengthy-vary fires. Nonetheless, Russia may maybe well maybe even beget misfortune with a sustained ground offensive a long way beyond Russian railroads with out a indispensable logistical end or a extensive mobilization of reserves.¹⁴ Because the operational depth in Ukraine is a long way bigger than in the Baltics, a Russian invasion of Ukraine may maybe well maybe even be an extended affair than some stay up for on account of the time and distance to bring up presents. If the invasion is now not any longer concluded immediate on account of a mix of weather, logistics, and Ukrainian resistance, how may maybe well maybe this affect Russian morale?

Morale: There are two levels of morale on every aspect to retain in tips: the morale of particular particular person squaddies and the morale of every nation and its other folks. On the actual particular person level, will a Ukrainian soldier who believes he or she is combating for their fatherland beget a bonus over a Russian soldier whose motivation for combating may maybe well maybe also vary? For the Ukrainian nation as an whole, how sturdy is their sense of a obvious nationwide id to withstand what may maybe well maybe even be a lengthy, harmful, and bloody battle? The solutions can’t be known till the war begins. Nonetheless, must war approach, one element influencing morale will most certainly be time. The longer the Ukrainian navy resists the Russians, the bigger its self assurance may maybe well maybe also grow as effectively as its institutional data of easy options to fight this enemy. To boot, the longer the war continues, the bigger may maybe well maybe be the level of world toughen and the bigger the probability of elevated hands transfers to abet turn the tide on the battlefield.

For Russia, the longer the war continues and the bigger the casualties, the bigger the probability of undermining Russian morale from the level of the elementary soldier to Russian society writ effectively-organized. Roughly one-third of Russian ground forces consist of one-300 and sixty five days conscripts.¹⁵ These conscripts aid alongside expert squaddies, or kontraktniki, below a machine of hazing is named the dedovshchina. This machine is inappropriate for its abuses up to and including homicide, which is ready to erode unit brotherly love. Furthermore, heavy casualties will need immediate replacements, and reservists dropped at boost frontline objects beget got minute fresh coaching. Because the replace of expert squaddies decreases on account of casualties, and reservists and conscripts enlarge on the entrance line, the probability of unhappy unit brotherly love at the soldier level will upward push. If casualties and even defeats mount, concerns of brotherly love at the entrance would be mirrored in public unrest at dwelling.

Each Kremlin ruler is conscious of that indubitably one of the most quickest options to end a Russian dynasty or regime is to lose a war. While early Soviet assessments of the war in Afghanistan were hopeful, they now not at the moment was depressed. At a Politburo assembly on October 17, 1985, as an instance, Soviet chief Mikhail Gorbachev learn letters from Soviet voters expressing rising dissatisfaction with the war in Afghanistan—including “moms’ misfortune over the unnecessary and the crippled” and “heart-wrenching descriptions of funerals.”¹⁶ Because the Soviet war in Afghanistan dragged on, the prices—including in blood and money—were too excessive and outweighed any geostrategic advantages. Over the route of the war, nearly 15,000 Soviet squaddies were killed, and one other 35,000 were wounded.

Russian families are obvious to resent their squaddies being stale as cannon fodder, and the ubiquitous presence of mobile phone cameras and movies in this day’s world will develop squaddies’ complaints beyond their objects. Attributable to this truth, the demand for the Kremlin will most certainly be: the longer the war grinds on and society reacts to casualties and financial duress, how powerful are their preliminary wishes fee to them?

The U.S. and Western Response

A Ukraine that is willing to fight for itself is a Ukraine fee supporting. While the Ukraine of 2022 is now not any longer a supreme democracy, neither was once Poland in 1939 when Britain and France determined that their tips and safety pursuits made it mandatory to draw the line against Nazi aggression alongside its borders. The major to thwarting Russian ambitions is to forestall Moscow from having a immediate victory and to steal the financial, political, and navy costs by imposing financial sanctions, guaranteeing political isolation from the West, and elevating the prospect of a chronic insurgency that grinds away the Russian navy. In this war, Russia can beget the watches, nonetheless the West and Ukraine may maybe well maybe even beget the time.

Washington’s just wishes to be to deter Russian extinct operations in Ukraine by punishment—no longer denial. Deterrence by denial entails preventing an opponent from taking an action, comparable to seizing territory, by making it infeasible or no longer going to prevail. Absent a indispensable U.S. and European navy deployment to Ukraine, which President Biden has already dominated out since Ukraine is now not any longer a member of NATO, Ukrainian forces can’t prevent a posthaste deployment of Russian forces into Ukraine. Deterrence by punishment, alternatively, entails preventing an opponent from taking an action which capability that of the prices—comparable to nuclear weapons, financial sanctions, or an insurgency—are too excessive. Deterrence by punishment is possible if led by the USA. America and its European allies and partners must publicly and privately proceed to talk to Moscow that a extinct assault on Ukraine would open crippling sanctions from Western international locations, deepen Russia’s political isolation from the West, and trigger a Western-backed insurgency against Russian forces in Ukraine. America would beget to beget the lead. The populations of loads of European international locations, comparable to Germany and Austria, beget illustrious that they would resolve to remain neutral in a war with Russia.¹⁷

If deterrence fails and Russian forces invade Ukraine, the USA and its allies and partners must behavior loads of instantaneous steps:

• Implement extreme financial and monetary sanctions against Russia, including reducing Russian banks off from the global digital fee messaging machine is named SWIFT.
• Manufacture a Twenty-First Century Lend-Rent Act to give Ukraine with war materiel at no heed. Priority objects would consist of air defense, anti-tank, and anti-ship systems; digital battle and cyber defense systems; minute hands and artillery ammunition; automobile and plane spare aspects; petroleum, oil, and lubricants; rations; scientific toughen; and other wants of a navy inspiring about sustained combat. This attend may maybe well maybe occur through overt capability with the abet of U.S. navy forces, including particular operations, or it may maybe well well maybe even be a covert action licensed by the U.S. president and led by the Central Intelligence Agency.
• Present intelligence to permit Ukraine to disrupt Russian traces of verbal replace and supply, as effectively as warning of airborne and amphibious attacks and locations of all indispensable objects.
• Provide humanitarian toughen to abet Ukraine kind out refugees and internally displaced other folks. This assistance may maybe well maybe also moreover beget to be extended to NATO allies on Ukraine’s borders for refugees fleeing westward.
• Present financial toughen, including energy, to Ukraine and NATO allies on account of the expected disruption of Russian gasoline flows to Europe.
• Conduct public diplomacy and media broadcasts to Ukraine and globally, including in Russia, to describe precisely what’s going on.
• Practice diplomatic stress on Belarus to sing Russia entry to its territory to assault Ukraine. Here’s seriously indispensable which capability that of Russian employ of Belarus’ rail and avenue networks would threaten a strategic turning movement of Ukraine’s northern flank.
• Coordinate with nongovernmental organizations and the International Prison Court docket to doc all war crimes inflicted on the Ukrainian other folks and to inquire redress once the war is over. What befell to the Syrian other folks must no longer happen all any other time.

America and NATO wishes to be willing to produce lengthy-term toughen to Ukraine’s resistance regardless of what assemble it ends up taking. There has already been public debate about unconventional battle toughen to Ukraine must segment or all of Ukraine be occupied.¹⁸ Nonetheless, this selection wishes to be approached with a transparent working out of what is possible to cease—and what’s going to no longer be that you just will be ready to factor in. Russia has historically confirmed adept at destroying armed resistance actions, and given enough time, it may maybe well well maybe cease so all any other time. Its options against a Ukrainian resistance will most certainly be swift, say, and brutal.¹⁹ Any sanctuary that the resistance makes employ of, whether or no longer it is in rump Ukrainian or NATO territory, would be field to Russian overt or covert assault. Attributable to this truth, it may maybe well well maybe require the security of mountainous extinct forces to deter Russian actions in NATO territory. Furthermore, regardless of fragment of Ukraine’s border Russia may maybe well maybe also beget may maybe well maybe immediate resemble the Iron Curtain of the twentieth century, featuring heavy fortifications. The Berlin Wall was once a heavily-guarded concrete barrier, which included anti-automobile trenches, mesh fencing, barbed wire, a mattress of nails, and other defenses. This is able to well also be onerous to set up supply traces for a resistance across this kind of score 22 situation from any sanctuary.

While the Russians were adept at anti-resistance operations, they kind no longer seem to be adept at extinguishing nationalism. Any toughen to occupied Ukraine must moreover consist of capability to retain Ukrainian’s nationwide id, historic past, and language among its voters. While armed resistance would hearken to the 1980s toughen provided to the Afghan mujahedin, this assemble of toughen to take care of the Ukrainian nation would be extra in step with the abet provided to Polish Cohesion right through its struggles for freedom.²⁰

To boot, Ukraine may maybe well maybe doubtlessly prevent Russia from seizing and conserving all or most of its territory with U.S. and other world attend. As an illustration, Ukraine may maybe well maybe retain most of its maneuver forces aid a long way enough from preliminary Russian breakthroughs so they are not encircled. As Russian forces approach west, Ukraine must make intelligence to search out out Russia’s main thrusts, behavior deep strikes against its supply traces to power them into an operational end, and after they’re stopped, envelop and counterattack them. Cities must retain out as lengthy as that you just will be ready to factor in. Within the case of Kharkiv, railroads and bridges inner town wishes to be fully destroyed earlier than capitulation to further degrade Russian traces of verbal replace. If the Russian navy approaches the Dnepr River, its loads of dams would be opened and low-lying areas flooded. Airborne and amphibious assaults wishes to be isolated at the moment. Ukraine’s just wishes to be to forestall Russia from making any indispensable advances earlier than the onset of the Rasputitsa, or thaw.

Once mechanized movement is ground to a end by mud and supply concerns, airborne and amphibious pockets may maybe well maybe even be eradicated, and Ukraine will beget had enough time to mobilize and deploy its roughly 900,000-man reserve power. Hopefully, world attend will moreover originate arriving in the assemble of weapons systems to forestall Russia from achieving air superiority over Ukraine and allowing it to proceed to strike deep into the Russian navy’s rear to attrit reinforcements and supply traces. As weeks develop into months, world financial and monetary sanctions must originate to beget cease. The Kremlin would then be faced with a lengthy war, on the battlefield and off it, with minute end in see.

A Fresh Iron Curtain

The fresh field bears an eerie resemblance to Soviet decisionmaking in 1979 to invade Afghanistan. In that case, a minute coterie in the Politburo made the choice on their beget in step with nasty intelligence, unhappy perceptions of the world atmosphere, overly optimistic scenarios of success, and minute comprehension of the world political and financial costs they would face. A effort-versus-reward calculation of Russia achieving its political wishes must discourage it from an invasion. Its simplest option would be to proceed to rattle sabers, pursue diplomatic negotiations, and attend pro-Russian insurgents in Jap Ukraine—nonetheless to refrain from a extinct invasion. Nonetheless, President Putin has made excessive-profile requires and threats that will most certainly be very onerous to retreat from. Ought to still miscalculation, emotion, and unhappy crisis management overcome rational calculations and lead to extinct war, the world panorama will possible gaze a dramatic switch.

In his infamous Iron Curtain speech on March 5, 1946, British high minister Winston Churchill spoke darkly that “a shadow has fallen upon the scenes” of Europe that pitted democratic states against authoritarian ones. “From Stettin in the Baltic to Trieste in the Adriatic,” Churchill remarked, “an Iron Curtain has descended across the Continent.”²¹ A fresh Iron Curtain would be powerful extra awful—spanning Europe, the Middle East, and Asia and incorporating a fresh axis of authoritarian regimes that entails Russia, China, Iran, and North Korea. This fresh dividing line would switch alongside Russia’s borders with Finland and the Baltic states alongside NATO’s eastern flank; cut through Russian- and Iranian-supported international locations in the Middle East and Central Asia, comparable to Syria and Kazakhstan; and snake alongside China’s borders with India through East Asia to the South China Sea. If Russia were to invade Ukraine, the USA and other European states would must speed squaddies and materiel to NATO’s eastern flank—comparable to Latvia, Lithuania, Estonia, and Poland—in case the Russians threatened to approach westward. Russia may maybe well maybe moreover attempt and instigate a crisis in a single or extra of the Balkan states to interrupt up American and European consideration and resources. In Asia, Taiwan would possible be on alert about that you just will be ready to factor in Chinese actions to beget the island.

Countries comparable to Russia and China fancy energy and beget minute appreciate for weak point—including navy weak point. Competitors may maybe well maybe extra and further become a battle between rival political, financial, and navy systems—between authoritarian, say-managed systems and democratic ones. The illiberalism at the root of Chinese, Russian, Iranian, and North Korean systems is antithetical to Western Enlightenment values. They eschew freedom of the press, freedom of religion, free markets, and democracy. As Thomas Jefferson remarked, “Freedom of religion; freedom of press; and freedom of particular person. . . . The following tips assemble the spirited constellation, which has gone earlier than us and guided our steps through an age of revolution and reformation.”²² They were serious in winning the Frigid Battle against the Soviet Union, and so they’re staunch as indispensable this day.

“If the Western Democracies stand collectively in strict adherence to the tips of the United Countries constitution, their influence for furthering these tips will most certainly be extensive and no person is possible to molest them,” Churchill remarked in his Iron Curtain speech. “If alternatively they become divided or falter in their responsibility and if these all-indispensable years are allowed to scurry away then indeed catastrophe may maybe well maybe also weigh down us all.”²³ Hopefully, reason will prevail in Moscow, and Russia will no longer invade Ukraine. If there may maybe be an invasion, alternatively, the USA and its allies and partners beget to be willing to withstand tyranny.

Philip G. Wasielewski no longer too lengthy in the past retired after a 31-300 and sixty five days occupation as a paramilitary operations officer in the Central Intelligence Agency. Seth G. Jones is senior vice president and director of the International Security Program at the Center for Strategic and International Reviews (CSIS) in Washington, D.C., and writer most no longer too lengthy in the past of Three Unhealthy Men: Russia, China, Iran, and the Upward push of Irregular Battle (W.W. Norton, 2021).

The authors give particular on account of Joe Bermudez and Jennifer Jun for their assistance with satellite tv for pc imagery prognosis, as effectively as to Jared Thompson for his illustrious learn assistance. The authors moreover thank Jeeah Lee and William Taylor for their outstanding editorial and graphic kind toughen.

This immediate is made that you just will be ready to factor in by usual toughen to CSIS. No say sponsorship contributed to this immediate.

CSIS Briefs are produced by the Center for Strategic and International Reviews (CSIS), a non-public, tax-exempt establishment focusing on world public policy points. Its learn is nonpartisan and nonproprietary. CSIS does no longer beget train policy positions. Accordingly, all views, positions, and conclusions expressed on this publication wishes to be understood to be entirely those of the author(s).

© 2022 by the Center for Strategic and International Reviews. All rights reserved.

Please search the advice of the PDF for references.